Breaking News on Dairy Processing & Markets

EFSA gut/immune health meeting

Danone tells EFSA: Health claims “learning experience” is too costly

By Shane Starling , 07-Dec-2010

Loading...

The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has repeatedly emphasised that the 2006 EU nutrition and health claims regulation is a learning experience for everyone involved – from its health claims assessment panel to industry stakeholders, to the member states and the European Commission.

That may be so, but it is a highly expensive learning process, with the greatest burden of cost being borne by industry players like Danone, the company’s vice president of research and development in its dairy division, Frederic René, said after EFSA’s gut/immune function meeting in Amsterdam last week.

With Danone having twice submitted and then withdrawn dossiers for its probiotic yoghurts Actimel and Activia, citing a lack of clarity from EFSA at the time of both withdrawals, René said EFSA needed to be more communicative with applicants.

He said it was not acceptable that EFSA undertook its learning process by analysing dossiers and publishing opinions on them.

“It’s a trial and error process and I don’t think it is the right way to make a learning process.”

Like several others at the meeting, he proposed pre-screening of dossiers by EFSA’s Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) panel, a proposal NDA chief, Professor Albert Flynn, said was unlikely due to a lack of resources.

Lack of depth and precision

René said he was disappointed by the lack of specific guidance forthcoming at the meeting, save for some advice on clinical outcomes.

“In fact there is nothing really new,” he said. “We need to be more precise and maybe go in depth as proposed by many of the people attending the meeting.”

He said the situation remained unclear as to when health claim submissions for Activia and Actimel may be formally submitted to the process for a third time.

Related products

‘If kids don’t like it, you won't get far’: Daioni boss on healthy dairy drink success

‘If kids don’t like it, you won't get far’: Daioni boss on healthy dairy drink success

Welsh farmer turned entrepreneur Laurence Harris tells BeverageDaily.com about his nationwide distribution ambition for...

Squash to smoothie enhancers: DreamPak scans horizon in $400m market

Squash to smoothie enhancers: DreamPak scans horizon in $400m market

DreamPak’s international sales director tells Ben Bouckley that brands must differentiate to grow in...

Lifting one child policy could boost whey protein demand: Volac

Lifting one child policy could boost whey protein demand: Volac

Michael Hiron

Commercial Manager, Lifestyle Nutrition, Volac

Industry must debunk whey protein bodybuilding myths: Volac

Industry must debunk whey protein bodybuilding myths: Volac

Michael Hiron

Commercial Manager, Lifestyle Nutrition, Volac

UK wasn't ready for Upbeat 5-years ago: Volac chief

UK wasn't ready for Upbeat 5-years ago: Volac chief

Mark Neville

Owner and Director of Human Nutrition, Volac

Fed up: Probiotic research veteran issues global call to action

Fed up: Probiotic research veteran issues global call to action

Veteran probiotic researcher professor Gregor Reid is not a happy man. It’s time the...

Consumer packaging feedback key to cracking new markets: Tetra Pak

Consumer packaging feedback key to cracking new markets: Tetra Pak

Tiziana Molaro

Lead User Experience Researcher, Tetra Pak

FIE 2013: FoodNavigator team round-up

FIE 2013: FoodNavigator team round-up

Our team of journalists is back in the office after three very busy days...

DSM goes 'back to basics' with yogurt cultures concepts

DSM goes 'back to basics' with yogurt cultures concepts

Pete Budde

Product Line Manager for Fermented Milk Products and Direct Vat...

Food Vision 2014: Bridge knowledge gaps, overcome change and work sustainably

Food Vision 2014: Bridge knowledge gaps, overcome change and work sustainably

What is the future of food? Simple communication of complex advances will be crucial,...

Innovation for today: Digital tech empowers industry to innovate

Innovation for today: Digital tech empowers industry to innovate

Chris Cornyn

founder & president, DINE Marketing

Global probiotic market to add 50% to €33bn by 2018: Analyst

Global probiotic market to add 50% to €33bn by 2018: Analyst

Ewa Hudson

Global head of health and wellness research , Euromonitor International

Festive video insights: Mintel experts offer up highlights and predictions

Festive video insights: Mintel experts offer up highlights and predictions

With 2013 fast drawing to a close and 2014 just around the corner, we...

Clean labels, transparency and the rise of Greek yoghurt: Ingredion talks top European trends

Clean labels, transparency and the rise of Greek yoghurt: Ingredion talks top European trends

Jorgen Kokke

Vice president and general manager, EMEA, Ingredion

Protein has a big ‘ordinary’ future, says Glanbia

Protein has a big ‘ordinary’ future, says Glanbia

Carla Clissman

European commercial director, , Glanbia Nutritionals

Another BRIC in the weight management wall as sector hits $150bn globally in 2013

Another BRIC in the weight management wall as sector hits $150bn globally in 2013

Ewa Hudson

Global head of health and wellness research, Euromonitor International

Filtration not a 'complete replacement' for heat treatment in dairy: GEA

Filtration not a 'complete replacement' for heat treatment in dairy: GEA

Bruce Blanchard & Pierpaolo Mattana

GEA Process Engineering

Sustainability 'playing a big role' in US dairy: IDFA

Sustainability 'playing a big role' in US dairy: IDFA

Cary Frye

Vice President, Regulatory and Scientific Affairs, International Dairy Foods Association...

Key Industry Events

On demand Supplier Webinars

High Pressure Processing for Beverages
Avure Technologies
Bottling solution for Liquid dairy products
GEA Process Engineering Inc.
All supplier webinars