Rabobank takes cold comfort in EU cheese
That’s according to a new report from financial services provider Rabobank, entitled The European Cheese Market.
While cheese has traditionally been the preferred outlet for milk from the EU after fresh milk needs are satisfied, the report authors insist that times are changing.
They explain that a mature EU cheese market is experiencing falling growth and margin pressure, due to higher revenues for milk powder and butter products that are pushing up raw milk prices for cheese producers.
With EU milk quotas set to end in 2015, milk suppliers will need to find new ways to deal with the excess milk produced therafter, according to Rabobank.
Cheese has traditionally provided better export opportunities than any other dairy product, since consumer willingness to pay for quality European cheese has always been high despite relatively high prices.
Consequently, the share of EU milk processed into cheese rose from 43-45% between 2001 and 2010, Rabobank said.
The report predicts that the EU cheese market continue to grow, but will do so at a declining rate: 0.6% across all Member States between 2011 and 2015 as against 1.1% from 2005-2010.
And 2%+ growth rates in Ireland, Poland and Hungary, and 1-2% in Sweden, Spain, Greece are offset by almost static growth predictions for Germany and France.
A saturated EU cheese market has eroded the higher premium associated with cheese compared with other dairy products, said Rabobank, while commodity volatility has also hit producers.
Milk powders and butter oil offer more attractive prospects than cheese nowadays, Rabobank said, as developing dairy markets in the Middle East and Asia demand these products.
Returns for even popular EU commodity cheeses such as Cheddar, Gouda and Emmental used to be higher than for skimmed milk powder (SMP) and butter.
“This meant that cheese producers could easily pay competitive prices for milk and still generate decent margins,” Rabobank said.
But in 2007 the traditional EU cheese maker premium disappeared, Rabobank said, as demand for milk powders grew faster than for cheese, with expanding markets such as China and Vietnam supplementing their supplies of the former and milk prices fluctating wildly.
In hard and semi-hard cheeses, maturation processes that can last over a year further complicate things for producers, creating a “time lag that makes a market-driven approach very difficult in these cheese types,” the report authors said.
“When the cheese has been produced in times of high raw material prices, but is not sold until a period in which the entire dairy market has turned around and wholesale price are low, margins can even become negative.”
But growing demand for SMP and butter does not mean that EU dairy producers should forget cheese entirely, given that EU milk still cannot compete in the world commodity arena, said Rabobank.
Rabobank suggested strategies for EU cheese firms that include consolidation and brand-building, and offering added-value retail solutions via dedicated marketing.
Companies can also offer secondary processing services and develop processed cheese ingredients for food firms, a sales avenue where Rabobank said manufacturers have “failed to recognise the possibilities”.
Greater flexibility in product portfolios would also avoid the need to ride the “highs and lows” of the global market, as would targeting exports outside the EU where developing market demand for fresh milk leaves little room for cheese production.